2025-2026 Price List

Fresh baked goods made with love

Christmas Order Deadline: December 15, 2025

Cookies
Pies
Cakes & Cheesecakes
Rolls & Breads

Cookies

Cookie Tray

11x15 tray • 30 cookies

Assorted cookies arranged on a convenient serving tray.

🍪 Cookie Tray Calculator

Select your favorite cookies and get instant pricing

Includes tray. Available cookies: Frosted Sugar, Molasses Crinkle, Snickerdoodles, Triple Chocolate, White Chocolate Oatmeal Cranberry, Grasshopper Bars, Hello Dolly Bars.

*Bar pricing calculated as equivalent per-dozen rate for tray portioning.

Frosted Sugar Cookies

$25 per dozen

Grandma Claudia's recipe. Homemade soft cookies with buttercream frosting in seasonal shapes.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Molasses Crinkle Cookies

$18 per dozen

A traditional molasses crinkle cookie made with love, pure molasses, and real butter.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Snickerdoodles

$18 per dozen

A classic soft buttery snickerdoodle rolled in cinnamon and sugar.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Triple Chocolate Cookies

$32 per dozen

Actually has four chocolates: bittersweet, milk, and white chocolate chips in a Dutch cocoa cookie batter. Decadent homemade cookies with a fudgy consistency – these make store-bought chocolate cookies weep with regret!

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

White Chocolate Oatmeal Cranberry Cookies

$25 per dozen

Perfect homemade soft holiday cookies loaded with white chocolate chips and dried cranberries, beautifully drizzled with real white chocolate.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Grasshopper Bars

$50 for 20 bars

One of my signature holiday treats. A favorite among family and friends. A family recipe from Arlice. A premium quality fudgy chocolate brownie with a layer of peppermint cream cheese frosting topped with a bittersweet chocolate ganache. Cut into treat sized bars.

20 2x2" (approx) bars

Hello Dolly Bars

$36 for 15 bars

Graham cracker cookie crust layered with sweet coconut flakes, walnuts, premium-quality bittersweet chocolate, gooey sweet cream. Rich and delicious with so many flavors and textures. A crowd pleaser.

15 2x2" (approx) bars

Pies

Chocolate Cream Pie

$36

Chocolate cookie crust filled with a firm, homemade creamy and velvety high-quality chocolate filling.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Grandma's Dutch Apple Pie

$32

Features a delicious crumble topping with a homemade buttery pie crust, packed with pounds of thinly sliced tangy and sweet apples.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Pumpkin Pie

$25

Perfect pumpkin pie spice blend in a creamy custard filling, nestled inside a homemade buttery pie crust.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Cakes & Cheesecakes

Carrot Cake

$50

10-inch round layer cake with cream cheese frosting. Made from my mom's recipe with hand-shredded carrots, walnuts, coconut, and pineapple. A moist, delicious, and perfect carrot cake.

New York Cheesecake

$55

10-inch round, creamy, traditional cheesecake. Features a graham cracker crust and sweet sour cream glazed top, water bath baked to perfection.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Pumpkin Cheesecake

$60

10-inch round, creamy, perfectly pumpkin pie-spiced cheesecake. Features a graham cracker crust and sweet sour cream glazed top, water bath baked to perfection.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Tiramisu

$60

Coffee and liquor-soaked lady fingers layered with homemade sweet and creamy Sabayon, topped with high-quality cocoa powder.

Rolls & Breads

Butter-Top Dinner Rolls

$20 per dozen

These soft and fluffy rolls are lighter than air and melt in your mouth – you can't eat just one! Made from grandma's homemade recipe with love and tradition.

Cinnamon Rolls

$36 per dozen

Loaded with good cinnamon, brown sugar goodness, and real butter. These soft, melt-in-your-mouth rolls come with traditional icing. Upgrade to cream cheese frosting for $4 per dozen.

Loaf of Pumpkin Bread

$20

A delicious homemade pumpkin bread topped with real melted butter and sugar.

Gluten-free option available (+$5). Our gluten free options are appropriate for gluten sensitivities but may not be suitable for allergies due to preparation in a shared kitchen with wheat flour.

Many of our items can be made with gluten-free flour or dairy alternatives for dietary sensitivities.